While I'm just entering the HD world and I love watching football and playing games in HD (at my friends house - he owns a 360 and a PS3) I don't think HD is as perfect yet. One of my biggest (humble) gripes is that most HD set's are large and make regular 480i broadcasts look terrible. I moved from a 36" 480i to a 52" 1080i and HD stuff looks great but standard 480i stuff looks absolutely horrible (so much so that I'll go up to my bedroom to watch standard view broadcast on the old 36").
When someone can make a big set that does well displaying 480i or when many more networks broadcast in HD we'll be closer to HD perfection.
My 2 cents. Uh - Can I have'm back
myspace.com/chevaliermusic