Like I asked, have I lost the really good ending by killing Eddie at the exit of the Prison Labyrithn? If so, it's too late 'cause I've saved at the Hotel, but I would like to know. If I did, tell me what I should have done!

About this issue on how to get the best ending on Silent Hill... on SH1 I had the same problem.... I think they give you no clues about what you should do to get the best ending, like...
1- At the hospital you go to the kitchen and have to pay VERY good attention to notice one of the bottles is collectable whitch is ok!
2- You MUST think wild about everyhting and imagine you could put that red stuff (at the storage room or what's-it's-name) on the bottle. Okay, that's fair enough...
3- But how can you imagine you have to use it to cure the police woman (Cybil?, I don't remember) on that twisted marry-go-round? Do they give us clues about this? I haven't seen none...
Oh well... too easy would be boring but I think it's very frustrating to end, i.e., SH1 and see that he just died when he had the accident at the beggining of the game... and TADA! * stay cool ppl! *:thumbsup: